The first time I met Eric, one warm evening in late May, I told him how much I hated the title of one of his poems. (I am a noted conversationalist.) We were at a party unveiling the latest edition of the college lit magazine, which I’d worked on, and two or three of Eric’s poems had been selected for publication, including the one I fought vehemently against because of its horrid title. (It really was bad.)
Totally unfazed, Eric grinned, told me I was wrong, and joined the magazine’s staff in the fall so that we could bicker more frequently. He walked me home every Monday night, always laughing.
Two years later, we finally realized that we were madly in love with each other.
Three months and twenty-seven days before our wedding day — seventeen months and two days after our first kiss at Logan airport — Eric was dead.
That was six years ago today.
In the six years since Eric died (I am allergic to euphemisms, at least when it comes to death), I’ve never been able to write coherently about our few years together, his death, or the aftermath. Over the past month I’ve written pages and pages of material, but it’s too much to post here, though it was, in the greater scheme of things, an ordinary tragedy. There was no bomb, no gun, no collapsing bridge, no drunk driver. No earthquake or tsunami or tornado or wasting disease. There was no one, nothing to blame, but there is so much to tell.
I could tell you about how much Eric loved his family and his best friend, Andy, his generosity of spirit, his quick wit, his inimitable brand of hard-edged sensitivity. But then I’d have to tell you about Eric’s walk (jaunty, purposeful, often with a cup of black coffee in hand), his laugh, his eyes, his fearlessness, the long tails on his handwritten ‘y’s, his inexplicable love for soccer, Miller High Life, and rap.
I could tell you about his poetic exploits (he wrote a sonnet composed of advertising slogans, and it worked), about the funny, bawdy, homely, happy poems he dashed off two or three times a week for me, about the play he wrote without telling anyone. I could tell you how the last time we talked I said I thought some of the poems in his thesis were ours, too personal to share. But then I’d need to tell you how we laughed about brazier/brassiere, how proud I was when he was published, how modest he was when other poets praised his work.
I could tell you about screaming into my apartment’s floor after Eric’s father called to tell me he was dead (the carpet was beige and cream with little brown fibers threaded through its flat twists, like loose hairs). But then I’d have to tell you about smashing glasses in the kitchen, curling up next to my best friend and hearing my mom ask him through the phone if I was vomiting, because I was sobbing so hard — and I wouldn’t be past the first two hours.
I could tell you that it is absurd (one of Eric’s favorite words) to be twenty-three years old and shopping for a black dress when there’s a perfectly good meringue of a wedding dress at home that you won’t ever wear. It’s absurd to wonder if there are support groups for almost-widows (There weren’t.). But then I’d have to tell you the absurdity of trying to explain your fiancé’s best qualities to a minister who’s never met either of you before, the absurdity of listening to a woman who verifies your relationship with the dead man in the casket twenty feet away and says, “Just think! All those birthdays! All those Christmases! And your wedding!”
I could tell you what it’s like to think that the evidence of spring around you is worse than absurd — it’s obscene. Obscene that all those flowers and budding trees are licked with sunshine when your beloved’s body is going down, down, down into the dark earth where you can’t follow. But then I’d have to tell you about reading an autopsy report, a calm account of your lover’s body cut to pieces, learning, at the last, just how heavy a heart can be.
You see, April really is the cruelest month.
The truth is, I’ve never written before about the aftermath of Eric’s death because to remember it, for me, is to relive it. One memory leads to another, and another, and another; what I’ve written here is only a fraction of what’s still in my mind. I can hear our wedding rings clinking on a chain around my neck, can see the anguish in his mother’s eyes, can taste the dust from the gravel road into the graveyard. I did not — do not — handle bereavement with grace or humor or equanimity or courage or any admirable quality at all, really. The desire to write these things down is mostly selfish, an attempt to share the witness of grief, to excise just a few of those memories.
That’s one half of the truth. The other half is that love is stronger than death.
What’s stronger than the awful memories of the week of Eric’s death and burial is the enormous power of the acts of love that happened in the weeks and months and years that followed. If I were to list every person who was kind to me, to Eric’s family, to my family, you’d be reading for hours. I kept every message, every letter, every note sent with flowers; impossible as it seems, I remember every person at the wake and funeral, every kind word then and after, and my gratitude is unceasing. For every agonizing memory, there are two or three filled with images of love. Most of them are so specific that I can’t write about them here without infringing on other people’s privacy; so suffice to say that when life felt most unlivable, somehow kindness always appeared in one of its many guises — a cornucopia of grace that I’m convinced saved my life.
There’s a particular solace that books can give, the sense that someone else has been there before you, has staked out the country, is holding out a rough-hewn cup when you’ve been so thirsty for so long that you’ve forgotten the taste of water. Mercifully, the last book I had to teach before the summer was The Razor’s Edge, and I’d never understood it better. I re-read C.S. Lewis’s A Grief Observed. My friend gave me Ann Hood’s Comfort. And there was poetry — so much poetry: Edna St. Vincent Millay, Emily Dickinson, Carol Ann Duffy, W. H. Auden, Milton, A. E. Housman.
And finally the ghost of Miss Havisham appeared and I decided that while I had no intention of falling in love ever again, I also had no intention of withering away in my apartment, or forever provoking (kind) looks of pity.
And so, about a year after Eric died, I found myself in a little Italian restaurant, sitting across from a tall near-stranger with warm brown eyes. He was shy, funny, serious, and, as I learned later, very kind and very gentle. I told him about Eric and my almost-widowhood on that first date, and he looked me in the eyes when he said he was sorry. He emailed me and asked for another date the same night. And in the last five years, he’s listened whenever I needed to talk about Eric.
It was confusing, at first, to fall in love when I still loved Eric; but finally I realized that I will never stop loving him. After all, we love relatives who’ve died, don’t we? The condition of their existence does not alter our love.
Last year, around this time, I wrote a little about what it’s like now to feel this mixture of love and sadness. For now, I can’t improve upon it, so here it is:
The end of a long story of mine is that I own the poetry collection of someone I loved very deeply and who died much too young. In the beginning I kept our collections separate, and thought that someday I’d try to read through them as a way to work through my grief. But over time the project receded, and our collections have melded together so thoroughly that often I don’t know the provenance of a particular book.
This morning, my little son, H, and I were looking over the shelves to find a poem to work on this week, and I was drawn to Richard Wilbur’s New and Collected Poems (1989), which won the Pulitzer (Wilbur’s second). It’s a thick volume, and I found several promising poems, full of sly wit and concrete images, but nothing that shook me by the shoulders and said “This one!”
Until, that is, as my son fell asleep in my arms, I read the title of the last section: The Beautiful Changes, the title of Wilbur’s first book of poetry, published in 1947, when he was twenty-six (oh, to have the touch of genius!). My hands shook a little; I know these poems, “Cicadas” and “O.” I’ve read poems that talk to them.
And the last poem in the book, in the collection, is “The Beautiful Changes,” and it expresses, for me, what has happened since I lost this person I loved, whose fingers turned these very pages. Through the madness and the crushing weight of sorrow, the images that I cannot un-see, life and consolation reached out and found me.
I knew, without looking, that if I opened the inside back cover, I’d find three angular initials, and that they wouldn’t be mine.
But now the poem is ours.
Portrait of His Beloved
John Donne knew a compass could draw
the face of a clock, but not the face
of his woman. To the young poet,
did this difference mean anything?
He knew her hands, no matter how gentle,
held him, in the end, the same way
as the clock’s hands held him.
To be away from her was to know
the hour. It was to know death
could be any unknown moment.
He loved her likeness, because
it was its moment kept in its frame.
Looking gave him time to ignore
the strange numbers never smiling.
Eric Van Cleve, 2006
44 thoughts on “Death of a Poet”
I am breathless, and in tears. (More to come…)
Your email and post were the first things I read this morning when I woke up and I think your words are going to stay with me for a very long time to come. Just as you wrote, “It was confusing, at first, to fall in love when I still loved Eric,” I, too, am sitting here thinking that I wish April and spring didn’t have to be this way for you…at the same time that I am feeling so happy that you found incredible love twice in your lifetime.
You made Eric come alive for me through your words. I feel like I saw and heard him.
I loved this so much, Carolyn. And the courage and love it took to put it all into words.
Thank you so much, Cecilia, especially for writing the first comment on this post, which made me feel like I wasn’t crazy for writing and posting it after all. 🙂
Carolyn, this is beautifully written. As the tears stream down my face thinking of you, all I can say in my very inarticulate way, is I Love You.
I love you too 🙂 Thanks for reading, Elena.
This post is beautiful, Carolyn. I’ll be thinking about it and you all day (and probably longer than that). Thank you for sharing it with all of us. [hugs]
Thank you, Heather.
This was beautiful. Love you, Carolyn. AP
Thanks, AP. I love you too.
This made me cry. I hope, at some point in your life, April stops being cruel.
It’s a little better every year, and when your two-year-old demands that you make brownies, it’s hard to stay sad.
Keep making those brownies!
A lovely remembrance. Wishing you peace today, and always.
Thanks, Kate. You’re one of those people, you know. And Thomas, too.
This is so beautiful. Thank you for sharing Eric with us. Like everyone who’s read this, I’m crying.
Thank you for reading, Ariel. I was lucky to know him, and doubly lucky to get a second chance at true love with Mr. O.
Too beautiful for words. Anything I write would be inadequate. Thank you for sharing your heart and Eric with us.
Thank you, CJ — it made me feel better to do it. 🙂
This is beautifully written, and your words left me sobbing. I’m so sorry for your loss and the hard thing that it is to remember, Carolyn. I love what you said about kindness, and I hope that many more kindnesses continue to help you through this.
Thank you, Emily — I’ve been very lucky in my friends and family and in my wonderful husband. You know how Mr. Rogers said to “look for the helpers”? That’s what my life is full of — helpers. And you’re one too.
Thank you, Meredith! Thank you for reading.
I am in shock, and like everyone else, I am crying. I can’t imagine having this happen, but the way you wrote about it is so beautiful. I love your message that love is stronger than death, and I am so glad you held on long enough to realize this so you could live to love again. Thank you for sharing your story.
Thank you. -Tania
Thank you for reading, Tania.
My dearest Carolyn, thinking of you today, especially. You are such a graceful person, with beautiful words, and a more beautiful heart. I love you! – Jenna
Carolyn – I just met you briefly, at Eric Funeral. What you wrote is so real, pure, powerful, raw, and amazing. Thank you for sharing this.
Thank you, Kevin. I do remember meeting you, and I know how much you and Cheryl have done to take care of Eric’s parents — thank you for that, too.
Carolyn–you have such a beautiful heart and such a beautiful mind. Courage to you, lovely friend. Thank you for sharing. Love, Heather
Thank you for being so supportive and lovely and generous all these years. I still remember hugging you on the sidewalk by the parking lot at Bay State Road, and the way the sun was shining through those trees. You were the first person I saw when I came back to the office. Love to to you.
So well said, Carolyn. We are thinking of you on this difficult day.
Thank you Aunt Nancy — you and Uncle Richard have been so kind and wonderful to all of us.
Carolyn, this took my breath away. Anne
“I could tell you what it’s like to think that the evidence of spring around you is worse than absurd — it’s obscene. Obscene that all those flowers and budding trees are licked with sunshine when you’re beloved’s body is going down, down, down into the dark earth where you can’t follow. But then I’d have to tell you about reading an autopsy report, a calm account of your lover’s body cut to pieces, learning, at the last, just how heavy a heart can be.
You see, April really is the cruelest month.”
When I read these words, my heart recognized you as a kindred spirit. My precious son Murray died on May 23, 2009, and seeing the beauty of spring today–the daffodils, the buds on the trees, the lovely breeze–my heart broke again. And reading his autopsy report did just what you describe, it taught me just how heavy a heart can be.
Thank you for capturing these feelings in such beautiful words.
Mary Ann Ward
Friend of Karen Van Cleve
The Compassionate Friends
I am so sorry to hear about Murray, Mary Ann. And I’m so sorry that those daffodils still bring you pain.
This is so very beautiful.
Thank you, Rory.
I believe we met a couple of times before Eric’s funeral, but certainly there at that wrenchingly sad event, where I don’t think any of us could yet do more than grasp at understanding the ungraspable. loss. At least I couldn’t.
I taught Eric at Ohio State in at least three poetry writing classes, and I’m still stunned by his death. I’d always assumed without thinking about it that he, with his enthusiasm and talent and self-mockingly combative passion for writing, would be a part of my life, and all of our lives, forever. Thank you for the lovely and sad glimpse into a part of his life I knew nothing about.
It may not surprise you to know that I am not a person who reads blogs. But Andrew (Hudgins) forwarded this to me. And I felt I had to write and say well said, well said. It may not bring you closure, but it will certainly give you perspective.
I hope all is well with you and yours.
Pingback: Recommended Reading: H is for Hawk, by Helen MacDonald | Rosemary and Reading Glasses
Pingback: “And early though the laurel grows / It withers quicker than the rose.” | Rosemary and Reading Glasses
Pingback: Recommended Reading: Stir, by Jessica Fechtor | Rosemary and Reading Glasses
Pingback: On Omnivorous Reading: A Tribute – Rosemary and Reading Glasses
Pingback: “And early though the laurel grows / It withers quicker than the rose.” | Rosemary and Reading Glasses